7 Christmas Baby Shower Favors: Easy DIY and Store-Bought Ideas

Category:
Explore Baby shower ideas

Christmas baby shower favors don’t have to be expensive or complicated. A small treat, a useful winter item, or a keepsake decorated with a baby-themed detail can give guests a thoughtful reminder of the celebration.

This list includes seven Christmas baby shower favor ideas, mixing homemade treats with ready-to-buy gifts. You’ll also find approximate costs, simple packaging suggestions, sample tag wording, and advice on when to prepare or order everything.

Whether your shower has a classic red-and-green theme, a soft pink Christmas palette, or a snowy winter wonderland look, these favors can be adjusted to suit your decorations and budget.

Key Takeaways

  • Mini hot cocoa jars, popcorn bags, and cookies are useful edible favor options.
  • Fillable ornaments, lip balm, and baby-themed soap make thoughtful keepsakes.
  • Custom-label matchboxes are a low-cost option for adult guests.
  • Plan for around 10–15% extra favors beyond your guest count.
  • Order personalized items early, especially for a December celebration.

Plan Before You Buy

Before ordering supplies or making favors, decide how many guests are coming, how much you want to spend, and whether you’ll prepare everything yourself. Christmas is a busy time for shops and delivery services, so a little planning can prevent last-minute shopping and rushed packaging.

Pro Tip: Choose your favor idea before buying ribbon, tags, or containers so you know exactly how much packaging you need.

Budget and Headcount Math

A reasonable planning range is around $1 to $5 per guest, with many simple favors falling between $2 and $3. Your final cost will depend on the item, packaging, personalization, and whether you buy supplies in bulk. Count your invited guests and prepare about 10–15% extra; for a shower with 30 guests, that means making approximately 35 favors.

Pro Tip: Work out the total cost before placing a bulk order, and include tags, ribbon, bags, and delivery fees in your calculation.

Order-By Dates

Try to begin preparing four to six weeks before the baby shower. Personalized Christmas ornaments, custom labels, and handmade gifts from online sellers may need extra time, especially during the holiday shopping season. Homemade favors can usually wait until closer to the event, but edible items need their own preparation schedule.

Pro Tip: If your shower is in December, order personalized favors early rather than relying on standard holiday delivery times.

The Catch

Shipping delays can become a problem during the first half of December, when many people are ordering Christmas gifts and decorations. If your shower is scheduled for a December weekend, aim to order custom items by early November. Keep a simple backup idea in mind in case a personalized order arrives late.

Pro Tip: Choose one favor that you can assemble locally as a backup, such as cocoa jars or small treat bags.

Edible and Drinkable Favors

Edible Christmas baby shower favors are a practical choice because guests can enjoy them at home instead of finding space to store another decorative item. Cocoa, popcorn, and cookies are also easy to package in small portions, making them suitable for different guest counts and budgets.

Pro Tip: Package food in containers that close securely, and include ingredient or allergy information whenever possible.

1. Mini Hot Cocoa Jars

Mini hot cocoa jars are a lovely match for a winter baby shower, especially when decorated with red ribbon, kraft tags, and a small peppermint topping. For around 35 favors, you could use eight-ounce jars, store-bought cocoa mix, mini marshmallows, crushed peppermint, and printed labels. The approximate cost in the original planning example is $2–$2.50 per jar, depending on the supplies and pack sizes you find.

Pro Tip: Leave some space at the top instead of filling each jar completely; this keeps the layers neat and gives guests room to mix the ingredients.

What you’ll need for approximately 35 jars:

  • 35 eight-ounce jars with lids
  • About 18 cups of store-bought cocoa mix
  • 2 bags of mini marshmallows
  • 1 bag of peppermint candies, crushed
  • Kraft paper tags and red ribbon
  • Round labels or a printable tag design

How to assemble them:

  1. Arrange the empty jars, ingredients, lids, and tags on a clean work surface.
  2. Add cocoa mix to each jar, filling it about two-thirds of the way.
  3. Place a layer of mini marshmallows on top, followed by a little crushed peppermint.
  4. Close each jar securely and decorate it with ribbon and a tag.
  5. Add simple preparation instructions, such as: “Stir 3 tablespoons into 8 oz of hot milk.”

For a group of 35, allow roughly 45 minutes if you have someone helping. A wide-mouth funnel makes filling the jars easier and helps keep the rims clean. Remember to mention that the cocoa mix contains milk if that applies to the brand you use, and check its packaging for other allergen warnings.

Pro Tip: Print the drink instructions and ingredient information on the back of the tag so guests have everything they need in one place.

2. Popcorn Bags with a Christmas Thank-You Tag

Small popcorn bags are an inexpensive favor when you want something quick to prepare. Fill clear cellophane bags with popcorn and tie each one with ribbon and a tag reading “Thanks for poppin’ by!” You can use red, green, gold, or silver ribbon to match the rest of your Christmas baby shower decorations.

Pro Tip: Prepare the popcorn on the morning of the shower and seal the bags well to help keep it crisp.

These are best suited to adult guests and older children. Avoid giving popcorn to children under four because it can pose a choking risk. If toddlers are attending, offer their families a different age-appropriate treat.

Pro Tip: Make a few alternative favor bags for families with young children instead of assuming every guest can enjoy the same snack.

3. Christmas Cookie Bags

Decorated Christmas cookies can double as edible favors and part of your dessert table. Snowflakes, little stockings, stars, Christmas trees, and baby-themed shapes all work well. Package one or two cookies in a clear bag with a ribbon and a tag such as “Sweet treats for celebrating our little one.”

Pro Tip: Choose cookie designs that are simple enough to decorate neatly in the time you have available.

If you’re baking at home, you can prepare the undecorated cookies ahead and freeze them. Decorate them closer to the shower, allowing royal icing to dry completely before placing the cookies in bags. If baking and decorating feels like too much work, ask a local bakery about individually packaged Christmas cookies; the original cost estimate is approximately $2–$3.50 per cookie, although local prices will vary.

Always check the ingredients and ask the bakery about possible allergens. Include a small ingredient label when you can, particularly if the cookies contain common allergens such as nuts, wheat, eggs, or milk.

Pro Tip: Store decorated cookies in a cool, dry place and avoid stacking them before the icing has fully set.

Keepsake and Cozy Favors

If you’d rather give guests something they can keep or use after the celebration, choose a small winter-themed gift. These options may cost more than popcorn or homemade cookies, but thoughtful packaging can make them feel connected to the baby shower instead of looking like ordinary Christmas gifts.

Pro Tip: Keep keepsake favors small and easy to carry so guests can take them home without needing a separate gift bag.

4. Clear Fillable Christmas Ornaments

Clear fillable ornaments are a nice choice for a Christmas baby shower because they can become part of the guest’s holiday decorations. Look for shatterproof acrylic ornaments in packs of 12–24, then fill them with paper stars, confetti, or shredded paper in the colors of your shower. The original estimate is around $1–$2 per ornament, depending on the size and material.

Pro Tip: Use lightweight decorations inside the ornaments so the filling doesn’t make them difficult to hang.

Add a small wooden tag with “Little Christmas Joy” on the front and the baby’s due date on the back. You can also use a cutting machine to add the baby’s initial in vinyl. For the favor display, hang the finished ornaments on a small tabletop Christmas tree and let guests choose one before leaving.

Pro Tip: Choose shatterproof ornaments rather than glass if guests will be carrying them in handbags or taking them home in cars.

One Caveat

Glass ornaments can crack if they are dropped or pressed against other items during the journey home. This is especially worth considering when guests have children with them or will be carrying several gifts. Acrylic or other shatterproof options are a more practical choice for a favor table.

Pro Tip: Test one filled ornament before assembling the full batch to make sure the top closes securely and the decoration stays in place.

5. Lip Balm with a Christmas Tag

Lip balm is a useful winter favor because it’s small, easy to carry, and simple to package. Buy a multipack of lip balm tubes, attach each one to a kraft paper card, and add a message such as “Thanks for celebrating with us.” The original estimate is around $1 per tube, though the price will depend on the brand and quantity.

Pro Tip: Choose individually sealed lip balms and keep the original product labels intact so guests can check the ingredients.

This favor takes very little assembly time and works with almost any Christmas baby shower theme. Use red or green cards for a traditional look, soft pink for a pink Christmas shower, or white and silver for a winter wonderland celebration.

Pro Tip: Attach the tube firmly to the card so it doesn’t slip off while the favors are being displayed or carried home.

6. Red Onesie Soap and Mini Candles

Baby onesie-shaped soap is a fun favor because its shape immediately connects it to the baby shower. Choose red soap for a traditional Christmas palette, or use white, blush, or another color that matches your decorations. Personalized soap favors from handmade sellers may cost around $2.50–$4.50 each according to the original estimate, so check the final price before ordering.

Pro Tip: Ask the seller about the soap ingredients and fragrance before buying, particularly if you want to offer an unscented option.

Mini candles are another option for a cozy holiday favor. Small candle holders or tealight sets can be packed in favor boxes, with the original estimate ranging from $3–$5 per guest. If you choose scented candles, keep the fragrance mild; strong scents may not suit every guest. Remember that candles with open flames need to be kept away from children and never left unattended. Battery-operated candles are a safer alternative for displays around young children.

Pro Tip: If you’re combining soap and candles, use a small box with separate wrapping so the soap doesn’t pick up the candle’s fragrance.

The Catch

Soap and candle favors usually cost more than simple edible gifts, especially when you add custom labels and boxes. They may be easier to manage for a smaller guest list, but the total can rise quickly for a large shower. Compare the full cost per guest before choosing these options.

Pro Tip: Use one keepsake favor for each guest rather than adding several small gifts that push the budget higher.

One More Cheap Favor

A low-cost favor can still feel thoughtful when the label and presentation match the party. If you need something inexpensive for a larger guest list, custom-label matchboxes are one option, although they should only be offered to adult guests and handled with care.

Pro Tip: Keep practical safety in mind when choosing favors, especially if children will be attending the shower.

7. Custom-Label Matchboxes

Small matchboxes can be decorated with printed paper bands featuring a Christmas baby shower message. Try wording such as “Our little spark is on the way” and use a simple red, cream, or green design. The original estimate is around 50 cents per matchbox, making this one of the lowest-cost ideas on the list.

Pro Tip: Keep matchboxes out of children’s reach and do not place them in favor baskets where young guests can pick them up.

You can give each adult guest one matchbox on its own or pair it with a small candle for a more complete gift. If children will be at the party, choose a non-flammable alternative for their favor bags rather than handing out matches.

Pro Tip: Check that the paper band doesn’t cover the safety information or interfere with the matchbox opening.

Match the Favor to Your Theme

Your favor doesn’t have to be identical to every decoration, but using the same colors and small design details helps the whole celebration feel coordinated. Choose the baby shower theme first, then select a favor and packaging style that fits it. Here are a few ways to match popular Christmas baby shower themes.

Pro Tip: Pick two or three main colors and repeat them on the favor tags, ribbons, and display table.

  • Classic red and green: Decorate hot cocoa jars with red ribbon, package Christmas cookies in clear bags, or use green tags with small holly details.
  • Pink Christmas: Try blush or pink fillable ornaments, pink ribbon, and cookies with soft pink icing. Keep the packaging light with white or cream accents.
  • Nightmare Before Christmas: Use black and purple treat bags, character-inspired ornament colors, and playful wording that suits the theme.
  • Winter wonderland: Choose white and silver ornaments, snowflake tags, pale blue ribbon, and clear packaging for a snowy look.
  • Woodland Christmas: Add wood-slice tags, small pinecone details, kraft paper, and forest-inspired colors such as brown, cream, and deep green.

Pro Tip: Let the favor packaging carry the theme instead of buying a completely different decoration for every gift.

Packaging and Tags That Look Store-Bought

Simple packaging can make even an inexpensive favor look carefully prepared. Clear cellophane bags, kraft tags, velvet ribbon, and small favor boxes are easy to mix with Christmas colors. You can make your own tags in Canva or print a ready-made template at home, then use the same design across different favor types.

Pro Tip: Make one sample favor first so you can check the tag size, ribbon length, and packaging before preparing the rest.

Here are three short messages you can print on your tags:

  • “Thank you for celebrating with us”
  • “Little Christmas joy”
  • “Thanks for poppin’ by”

Arrange the finished favors on a tray, in baskets, or on a small table near the exit. A simple sign saying “Take one, with thanks” helps guests know they can pick one up before leaving. Keep the gifts small enough to fit in a purse or sit safely in a car, and take a quick photo of the display before guests arrive.

Pro Tip: Put heavier favors at the bottom of baskets and delicate cookies or ornaments near the top to prevent damage.

👉 From festive balloon arrangements to charming table displays, the right decorations can bring the whole baby shower theme together. These Christmas baby shower decorating ideas offer inspiration for adding seasonal touches without losing the sweet feel of a baby celebration.

Christmas Baby Shower Favors FAQs

These common questions can help you decide how much to spend, how many gifts to prepare, and when to start making or ordering your Christmas baby shower favors.

Pro Tip: Make your favor decisions early so you can focus on the rest of the shower as the date gets closer.

How much should I spend per favor?

A useful starting budget is around $1–$5 per guest, with $2–$3 being a reasonable target for many simple favors. Homemade cocoa jars, popcorn bags, and bulk supplies may cost less, while personalized ornaments, candles, and handmade soap can be more expensive. Your final budget will depend on packaging, shipping, and local prices.

How many favors should I make?

Prepare one favor for every invited guest, plus around 10–15% extra. For example, if you expect 30 guests, making 35 favors gives you a few spares for unexpected visitors, additional family members, or damaged items.

Should I make or buy my favors?

DIY favors are a good choice for cocoa jars, popcorn bags, and printed tags because you can prepare them in batches and adjust the colors to your theme. Store-bought or personalized items, such as custom ornaments and onesie-shaped soap, can save time when you don’t want to handle the crafting yourself. A combination of homemade and ready-made gifts is often a practical middle ground.

When should I order or start?

Begin planning four to six weeks before the baby shower, particularly if you want personalized favors. For a December event, try to place custom orders by early November. Homemade decorations and packaging can be prepared closer to the date, while popcorn and other fresh edible favors should be made shortly before the celebration.

Back to the Jars

You don’t need an elaborate gift to thank guests for celebrating with the mom-to-be. A small jar of hot cocoa, a decorated ornament, a packet of cookies, or a useful winter item can make a thoughtful Christmas baby shower favor when it’s chosen and packaged with care.

Choose an idea that fits your guest list and budget, prepare a few extras, and give yourself enough time to finish the tags and packaging. The best favor is one guests can enjoy or use after the party without adding extra work to your celebration.

Author

  • SARAH

    I love sharing creative party ideas, fun games, baby shower inspiration, and practical home storage and organization tips to make every celebration and home feel special.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *